Showing posts with label editing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label editing. Show all posts

Saturday, August 3, 2013

Why Drafting Rocks Revising Out of the Water

I love the dramatic cloudscapes of New Mexico's monsoon season.

So, in this week's cage match throw-down over drafting vs. revising, for once I get the last word. That's because I was crazy helping my folks move last weekend and the always-helpful Veronica stepped right up to swap places with me.

It's getting a bit uncanny, how much alike James and I are. I'm glad he copped to feeling like something is wrong with him, because I'm there, too.

I really hate revising.

To me, revising means I screwed up the first time around. Yes, yes - I know you are are shaking your heads at me, perhaps fondly, more likely in irritation. But the truth remains that, in my heart of hearts, I believe that if I got the damn story correct the first time around, I wouldn't have to go back and fix it.

You have to understand that I'm also the girl who literally does crossword puzzles in ink (pencil is way too vague and smudgy). In college, I composed all of my papers on my Brother Correctronic typewriter (a blast from the past for all my fellow pre-PC folks out there) and turned them in that way. I learned early on to never go back and check my answers on exams - as the common wisdom instructs - because, if I changed my first answer, I inevitably changed it wrong.

I don't like getting things wrong.

Oh yes, this is compulsive, likely obsessive, perfectionistic and downright weird, but revising to me means fixing errors and it's wasted time that I could be spending writing the new thing, if only I'd gotten the previous thing right the first go-around.

This is not to say that I don't revise. I do.

And I grumble to myself the whole time.

However, as I become a better, more-practiced writer, my revision passes are becoming less involved. I inevitably have some smoothing to do at the beginning, since I discover all sorts of things along the way. By the time I've found out how the book ends, I usually need to tweak a few details at the beginning.

If I've done my job right, even my critique partner (CP) feedback only requires similar tweaking.

After that, I more or less cheerfully accommodate my editors' edits. The more involved developmental edits sometimes give me that "you screwed up" feeling, but more often I feel like it's taste or massaging to the market. Line and copy edits are no biggie. I don't care about commas. I accept most suggested rewordings.

One of my CPs insists that revision is holy work. That's exactly what she calls it.

For me, writing the story is the holy work. And if I'm diligent, clear-minded and true of heart, I'll get the story right as I write.

It's like being connected to the Tao, to the creative flow of the universe, pouring through me and into the work.

There's nothing else like it. Not even sex - and that's saying a lot.

Not a thing wrong with that.

Wednesday, July 31, 2013

EDITING vs. REVISING

To me, editing a novel means FIXING/AMENDING the nuts and bolts of a story. It can be correcting typos, cutting exposition, or tightening a scene for pacing purposes. It can be adjustments made to firm up logic, or address areas where the language is too flowery or too stilted.
OIL CHANGE


You know...it's an oil change, new brake pads--making what you have work better. It may mean adding those ass-kickin' skull emblazoned new seat covers you wanted to dress it up a bit, and it might be the opportunity to upgrade to that stereo and speaker system and that will really resonate and literally vibrates your little bug down the road.


Likewise, to me, revising a novel means tinkering with the engine and fuel source of a story. As in the main plot, the subplot(s), or character arc. It means changing something integral to the basis of the story, something which effects everything. Change the gender or race of your main character. Change the setting from modern day NYC to Victorian England. Instead of a heroine with a three-legged dog as a side kick, she gets a spunky kid sister instead. This is rewriting. Sometimes, it simply has to be done if you want to sell a story.

TRADE THIS OVERUSED STORY VEHICLE...


You know...it's taking that rusty and dented body in sky blue, the one you love so much, and allowing it to become more than you ever intended...reshaping it with tools and bondo, working it through a couple coats of primer, and ending up with a sleek and glossy cherry red. It's taking that reliable work-truck and trading it for something new and sporty, something more maneuverable and exciting.



...FOR THIS SLEEK, AGILE STORY VEHICLE



        So...if you are writing, then conceivably, editing is something you are quite able to do. Spell check, grammar, etc. There are resources available to correct the mechanical stuff.




Revising however, requires that you are willing.


Personally, when I have an idea and I get it onto the screen-page, a rough outline forms around it. Sometimes I write myself into a corner and have to revise everything. When I do reach the end, my self-editing ensues addressing mechanical issues while I debug and re-calibrate as needed.


If an established and reliable editor or agent with a proven track record offers suggestions based on what they see as needed for the story, or ideas that would improve the story and its impact on readers in a positive way, then Hell yes I am going to seriously consider how to address their concerns.

Don't be the author standing in the dark pit of some plot-hole that swallowed them alive, and shout up into the lighted world of the writing business (where sales are actually made), saying, "No I like it this way."




Tuesday, July 30, 2013

Editing vs Revising vs Rewriting


So... I'm a delinquent. No, no. Not because I'm posting this in the early summer evening. I'm a delinquent when it comes to claiming to be "editing" when, in fact, I've passed the point of "revising" and gone back to a straight-up rewrite.

For two years, CPs, friends, and family heard me claim to be "editing that same story." I wasn't. I'd gutted it. Kept 70% of the cast, the top line plot, and the opening chapter. Everything else changed. You know what that's called? Not editing. That's a full-bore rewrite.

Level of Effort is what differentiates Editing, Revising, and Rewriting ... to me. If folks who get paid to be particular about correlating the appropriate verbs to specific actions care to disagree, okay fine. In my little universe, if I'm making changes to police over-used words or correct syntax, then it's editing.  If I'm changing the order of events in chapters or cutting full scenes, then I'm revising. If I'm stripping everything back to the skeleton of the main plot, then that's a frippin' rewrite.

What about you, dear reader, where do you draw the lines among Editing, Revising, and Rewriting? Do you commit to the arduous changes of revisions and rewrites, or do you let the story go and move on to the next?

Photo courtesy of Grammarly on Facebook.


Thursday, January 10, 2013

Polished Perfection

by Allison Pang

It's been fun reading how people work their creative process this week. Like everything else about writing, editing can be a pretty personal thing - we've all got different ways of making sure we put out the best story we can. So what do I do before sending my manuscript out?

Well, for one thing - I finish it. I've come to realize that I *have* to have a finished draft. I've tried doing the "edit as I go with a crit partner" thing a few times and it's a complete disaster. I know that works for some people, but if I get too caught up in editing what I've got before the story is done, there's a real good chance it won't get done at all. It's too easy for me to get sucked into all the little details - for a panster like me, that's the kiss of death. (Plus, I know I've fallen into the "edit as procrastination" lull before. It's too easy to make the excuse that "I'm editing, so I don't need to write." Okay for a day or two, but more than that?

Nope.

Okay - so assuming I've got my rough draft in hand, what do I do?

1) Plot holes and rewrites.  This is possibly a bit more complicated than it sounds. Since I don't really edit as I write, if I change my mind partway through about a particular plot device, I note it in red and then continue writing the story as though I'd been doing it all along. (Seriously? In A Sliver of Shadow, there's a particular knife that kept appearing and reappearing in the draft because I couldn't quite figure out if Abby needed it at certain points or not, so it took me a while to get that straightened out. Also? I tend to rewrite about 50% of my books during this stage, though I'm trying to be better about it and maybe actually attempt to plot with these next few stories. I suspect I'll save myself a lot of effort in the long run. (Though this may just be how I work. I've often added stuff in at the very last moment during copyedits, so I don't know.)

2) Assuming I've got the story straightened out - now it's time for sentence polishing - getting rid of passive voice and odd turns of phrase. Also - each publishing house has it's own stylesheet - usually lists of words they want spelled a certain way, eg. toward vs towards. I usually hit these up at this point too.

3) Then we have grammar and whatever line editing I can do.  (There's no point in me doing it any sooner than this - why edit something I may take out later? Waste of time.) I'm notorious with word echoes - using the same word or phrase too close together. Like my fellow word-whores, I've got a list of the worst offenders. (Just, back, gaze, etc.) And while I do search them down, I also like to have fun with this part - so I will use a word mosaic to help me out. Specifically I use Wordle, but there are several out there that do similar things.

For example - here's the wordle created for my original draft of A Sliver of Shadow:


The words I use the most show up the largest. I'm not so concerned about Talivar, though perhaps it's worth going through to see if there's a better way of referencing him. But ugh - back, head, eyes, just, like? Yeah those are problems. 

After a I go over the manuscript several times and remove the echoes and tighten up the sentences, I'm left with this:


Is there still work to do? Absolutely, but look how much smaller "back" is! And I go back through it again. And again. I'm a pretty visual person though, so it's nice for me to actually see what sort of impact my edits are having. Ideally, I try to get the majority of the words to an even size, though it's not always possible.

4) At some point along the way, I've hopefully sent this off to beta readers and I go back and attempt to implement any changes that seem necessary. However - I've had to learn to be very careful with this. When I first started out, I was in a crit group and I had too many people looking at it - and I kept trying to make everyone happy. What I ended up with was several over-polished chapters that completely lost all sense of my "voice." (Ask Jeffe what A Brush of Darkness looked like during that time - she's the one that pointed it out to me and she was completely right.) Sometimes it's better for me to take a few steps away from the piece and let it sit for a week or so - being ruthless during editing is fine, but you don't want to edit out everything that makes the story yours, if that makes any sense?

5) I run through everything a final time, suck it up and send it off - to my agent or my editor, whichever needs it first. And then I sit and wait and wait and wait. Get my edits and weep for a bit and then start the process over again. ;-)

Rinse and repeat, as needed. (Or until the deadline hits, whichever comes first.)

Sunday, January 6, 2013

How I Clean Up My MSS Before Sending

A photo from our freezing fog the other day. (Another picture here.) I love the pattern of frosted vine and shadow. Layers upon layers.

Last week, my editor, the fabulous Deb Nemeth, and I finished up the copy edits on Ruby, the third book in my Facets of Passion series. (Amusingly, I tried to link to the series on Amazon, instead of just book 2, which I ended up doing. When I searched, Amazon asked me if I meant "Faucets of Passion." I'm totally writing that next!

At any rate, all the editing for Ruby went really fast, which was particularly great because we did them over the winter holidays, to meet a sale date four months earlier than expected. However, they also went faster because I've gotten smarter.

This is the fourth publication I've done with Deb. I know by now what she looks for and I've - gasp! - started fixing them before she asks me to. I actually created a checklist for my final polish before I send something back to her, to remind myself of my common errors.

So, that's why I suggested this week's topic of what kinds of final checks we all make before sending a manuscript. I'm really interested to hear what everyone else does. (And may add to my own list.)

Here's mine:

  • Search for [ ]

While I'm writing along, if I can't think of a word, want to check the brand name, need to check the previous book, etc. - basically anything that would halt the writing flow - I put it in square brackets as a placeholder. Sometimes I forget about them. My CPs usually catch them, but they shouldn't have to.
  • Search for “now” 
  • Search for “just” 
"Now" and "just" are my usual verbal tics. I use them ALL THE TIME. It drives me crazy. I don't even know I'm doing it. Most of them can just (see???) be deleted. Sometimes I have to restructure. I leave some in, but not fifty-million.
  • Replace towards with toward 
This is a Carina Press house rule. For some reason I'm addicted to towards, which is apparently more British. I fix them as a last step.
  • Search for endearment of the day 
Another of my tics. I have a name-thing. Most of my stories play with names and what people call each other. I don't know why I have this - I don't plan it out at all. But it ends up being fundamental to the characters and their interaction and sometimes their transformation. But I overdo it and Deb is forever asking me to reel it back. 
  • Search for actions as dialogue tags. 
Another Carina house rule, but that's probably good for me to learn. An example would be: "No," he picked up the chicken and threw it at her, "I won't cook you dinner!" I tend to construct this way. It would change to: "No!" He picked up the chicken and threw it at her. "I won't cook you dinner."
 (I feel like I should caveat that the above example is not an actual line from Ruby, or from anything else I would ever write. Chickens are not for hurting.)
  • Search for overused dialogue tags. 
Deb always reminds me that "said" and "asked" are just fine and are nearly invisible to the reader. I have to go through and remove a certain percentage of my livelier tags and tone it down a bit.
 So, there's my dirty editing laundry! What does everyone else do??