Tuesday, July 30, 2013

Editing vs Revising vs Rewriting


So... I'm a delinquent. No, no. Not because I'm posting this in the early summer evening. I'm a delinquent when it comes to claiming to be "editing" when, in fact, I've passed the point of "revising" and gone back to a straight-up rewrite.

For two years, CPs, friends, and family heard me claim to be "editing that same story." I wasn't. I'd gutted it. Kept 70% of the cast, the top line plot, and the opening chapter. Everything else changed. You know what that's called? Not editing. That's a full-bore rewrite.

Level of Effort is what differentiates Editing, Revising, and Rewriting ... to me. If folks who get paid to be particular about correlating the appropriate verbs to specific actions care to disagree, okay fine. In my little universe, if I'm making changes to police over-used words or correct syntax, then it's editing.  If I'm changing the order of events in chapters or cutting full scenes, then I'm revising. If I'm stripping everything back to the skeleton of the main plot, then that's a frippin' rewrite.

What about you, dear reader, where do you draw the lines among Editing, Revising, and Rewriting? Do you commit to the arduous changes of revisions and rewrites, or do you let the story go and move on to the next?

Photo courtesy of Grammarly on Facebook.


6 comments:

  1. Where did you get that picture of me while revising?????

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. While I was pilfering your chocolates... ~evil laugh~

      Delete
  2. Yep, that's pretty much my take on it, KAK. I'm nearing the end of a strange mix of edit, revise and rewrite now, though. Since I'm retyping the whole damn thing, though, I'm calling it a rewrite.

    It was the only way this sucker was going to work. :shrug:

    I usually commit and if commitment doesn't work, I let go. Then years later, I recommit. I'm like that sad divorcee who can't stop remarrying her ex-husbands - except I do have a chance of making these books change. ;o)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh that analogy...LOL! I confess, I do the same thing with stories I can't (but probably ought to) leave buried.

      Delete
  3. Gutted, de-boned, and filleted. I lift my wineglass to you!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Then we throw it back in the water to see if anything bites!

      Delete